How do I return an item purchased using Afterpay? November 26, 2020 04:21 Updated Simple! To return items purchased using Afterpay, follow Orgain.com's Return Policy. You do not need to contact Afterpay. Related articles Do you offer free returns? How do I request a return or exchange? Can I pay early? Where can I buy Orgain in the US? What is your return and exchange policy?